About

“Dogma and Reflection in the Psychoanalytic Encounter” ISPHS Symposium 2026
This year’s symposium is dedicated to exploring the tension between dogma and reflection—two forces that are ever-present in the life of both individuals and groups. The presentations we will hear are, in my view, remarkably inspiring and offer a fresh perspective on psychoanalysis, opening the way for a new reflective encounter within psychoanalysis, particularly in relation to analytic relationship, learning, and ethics. 
What unites these papers is a spirit of inquiry and openness—a readiness to move beyond fixed assumptions and to engage in dialogue with uncertainty. In an encounter where dogma and reflection do not exclude one another but generate a creative tension, the possibility of new, living psychoanalytic thinking emerges. 
Wojtek Hańbowski, in his presentation “The Ego and the Superego in a Never-ending Conflict,” analyzes the relationship between the ego and the superego, arguing that it is impossible to fully eliminate the harsh, dogmatic superego. Nevertheless, it can coexist with a reflective ego, forming a dynamic, though often painful, psychic equilibrium. Drawing on the concepts of Ronald Britton and John Steiner, he emphasizes that the struggle between these psychic structures is an ongoing process—both a condition for development and a source of suffering. Literary and clinical illustrations presented in the paper demonstrate that “standing up to” the superego is not a one-time act but a lifelong process.
Claudia Frank, in her paper  „Notes on ‘Re-orientation’ by Supervision. Misconceptions Threatening Emotional Pressures in Psychoanalytic Training to be Faced” shares her reflections on supervision as an encounter that may either support or inhibit the analyst’s development. She shows how mistaken beliefs and the emotional pressures arising from them (e.g., those stemming from the superego) that accompany training can lead to confusion for both candidates and supervisors. Drawing on the ideas of John Steiner and Roger Money-Kyrle, she introduces the notion of reorientation—a process through which supervision helps to regain the capacity to think and functions as an encounter for  “teaching and a little implicit treatment.” From this perspective, supervision becomes not only an educational tool but also a transformative experience. She extends the idea of reorientation to the institutional level, advocating for mutual support and reflection among training institutions.
Edyta Biernacka’s presentation, titled “Know you are loved”: Psychoanalysis and agential realism attempts to view psychoanalysis not only as a practice of understanding but also as one of co-creating psychic reality. She questions the opposition, present in some psychoanalytic concepts, between the ontological (“what is”) and the epistemological (“how we know”) and shows that in the analytic encounter these dimensions become intertwined within the relational and ethical sphere, understood as responsibility for the other and openness to their reality. Inspired by Karen Barad’s concept of agential realism, Edyta Biernacka explores how truth in psychoanalysis is not so much discovered as it is enacted between two people, becoming a factor of change. She refers to the series Bodies as well as fragments of clinical material to show that the experience of truth—lived rather than merely known—constitutes the essence of the psychoanalytic encounter.

On behalf of the Scientific Committee,
Agnieszka Hańbowska  

Scientific committee
Organizing committee

Speakers

Venue

Dom Polonii (Polish Community House)
64 Krakowskie Przedmieście St, Warsaw
Dom Polonii (Polish Community House), housed in the historic building of the former Resursa Obywatelska, has been a place of meetings and discussion since the 19th century. Today, it offers a natural backdrop for conversations on ideas, tensions, and disputes that call for reflection.

Program

9:00 - 10:00

Registration

10:00 - 10:15

Introduction

Małgorzata Bajor-Wocial, President of the Hanna Segal Institute for Psychoanalytic Studies

Agnieszka Hańbowska, Chair of the Scientific Committee

10:15 - 11.45
 Wojtek Hańbowski

Wojtek Hańbowski

Wojtek Hańbowski

The Hanna Segal Institute for Psychoanalytic Studies
Polish Psychoanalytical Society

 

The Ego and the Superego in a Never-ending Conflict.

 

Chair: Rafał Pniewski

11:45-12:15

Coffee Break

12:15 - 13.45
 Claudia Frank

Claudia Frank

Claudia Frank

German Psychoanalytical Association/DPV

 

Notes on ‘Re-orientation’ by Supervision.
Misconceptions Threatening Emotional Pressures in Psychoanalytic Training to be Faced.

 

Chair: Izabela Gogolewska

13.45-15.15

Lunch

15.15 - 16.45
 Edyta Biernacka

Edyta Biernacka

Edyta Biernacka

Polish Psychoanalytical Society
Polish Society for Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy

 

“Know you are loved”:
Psychoanalysis and agential realism.

 

Chair: Maciej Musiał

16.45-17:00

Closing remarks

Contact

The Hanna Segal Institute for Psychoanalytic Studies

Address

ul. Lanciego 9H, 02-792 Warszawa

Company details

KRS: 0000482352
NIP: 585-146-78-29
REGON: 221994104

Email address

sympozjum@isphs.pl

Phone number

+48 697 485 747